Guest post by Charles H. Langley.

Dic, hospes, doctis caelebs animalculum obisse

hicque iacere physis legibus conveniens.

(Stranger, tell the learned that the celibate little animal has passed away, and lies here, conforming to the laws of nature.)

—John Rundin, with apologies to Simonides and Cicero

Thirty-five years ago, in a celebrated News & Views (1986) John Maynard Smith shared his well-developed thoughts about the evolutionary forces that may have maintained sex in the surviving lineages of eukaryotes. While parthenogenesis appears to be widespread, phylogenetic analyses were establishing that the overwhelming majority of the ancient and successful lineages retained sex in all its biological richness. Simple population genetic theory had long raised the question: what is the evolutionary mechanism(s) that overcomes that clear two-fold Malthusian advantage of an asexual mode of reproduction? After highlighting a number of interesting asexual species, Maynard Smith disposed of all of these as young and likely to be evolutionary dead ends. One hundred years earlier, before the rediscovery of Mendel and the development of population genetic foundations for natural selection Weismann (1887) had already surmised that natural selection favoring sexuality in multicellular organisms must be strong.

Maynard Smith cast the bdelloid rotifers as the exceptions, being perhaps 40 million years on the earth, and even after centuries of study these beloved and easily collected and cultured micro-animals had not yielded a male. Maynard Smith’s reference to the bdelloid as “something of an evolutionary scandal” energized efforts to address this assertion. Perhaps the early rotifers had evolved a creative evasion of the strong evolutionary forces maintaining sex in other eukaryotic lineages? Or were bdelloids simply ‘modest,’ pursuing sexual reproduction rarely and/or in the most obscure environments? Both these hypotheses appeared tenable, although the force of the first depends on negation of the latter.

Over the ensuing decades the natural history and systematics of bdelloids improved yet no evidence of sex emerged. Meanwhile molecular geneticist Matt Meselson and colleagues proceeded to look at the bdelloid genomes. Ancient duplications were discovered. And then Nowell et al. (2018) found evidence for the conservation in bdelloids of genes associated with meiosis throughout all eukaryotes. For unknown reasons, the simple inference of sex in the population genetics of bdelloid rotifer species was only recently addressed. Independently two research groups have now reported evidence of sex in the recent descent of distinct bdelloid species (Vakhrusheva et al. 2020) and (Laine et al. 2021). Variants at genomic locations far apart or on different chromosomes occur in combinations that strictly asexual reproduction precludes, but mere occasional sexual reproduction strongly predicts. They concluded that, despite the lack of observed mating or even of “males,” these bdelloid rotifers must have had recent sexual common ancestors. Thus the ‘scandal’ of evolutionary biology is transformed into the latest evidence driving what is perhaps the most significant and controversial question in evolutionary genetics, what force(s) maintains sex in eukaryotes.

The lifting of a scandal often engenders rectification of respect and the drawing of lessons, if not morals. The generality of the observed conservation of sex is, indeed, bolstered by the new evidence in bdelloid rotifer. It also raises other questions. Should the study of the reproductive biology of rotifers have been given tenfold more resources and talent? After all it took 35 years. Or can one suggest that this decisive evidence of bdelloid sexuality would have come in the same amount of time without the impetus of the ‘scandal?’

The real substance of Maynard Smith’s short discussion was, of course, the mechanism of the natural selection that maintained sex. The accepted competing hypotheses rest on the indirect selection induced by linkage among loci under selection. As R.A. Fisher and H.J. Muller noted in the 1930s, in the complete absence of sex, strongly favored rare variants (mutations) must arise and go to fixation in a sequential order. In contrast, sexual reproduction allows unlinked variants to respond to natural selection independently. Thus, sexual populations can more readily adapt to changing environments. And that’s what we observe, i.e., asexual lineages go extinct.

However, as H.J. Muller always wanted us to remember, the great majority of mutations are deleterious and much, if not most, of natural selection is committed to their eventual purging from the population. What Maynard Smith was at that time just beginning to appreciate and in the ensuing decades has become widely recognized, is that linkage also impedes this mode of natural selection. Thus, the selection on deleterious mutations can indirectly select in favor of sexual individuals and thereby maintain this most conserved of eukaryotic life history traits. Happily, the charming bdelloid now stands proudly at the center of inquiry into the evolutionary impact of natural selection.

Literature Cited 

Laine V. N., T. Sackton, and M. Meselson, 2021 Genomic Signature of Sexual Reproduction in the Bdelloid Rotifer Macrotrachella quadricornifera. GENETICS https://doi.org/10.1093/genetics/iyab221

Maynard Smith J., 1986 Evolution: Contemplating life without sex. Nature 324: 300–301. https://doi.org/10.1038/324300a0

Nowell R. W., P. Almeida, C. G. Wilson, T. P. Smith, D. Fontaneto, A. Crisp, G. Micklem, A. Tunnacliffe, C. Boschetti, and T. G. Barraclough, 2018 Comparative genomics of bdelloid rotifers: Insights from desiccating and nondesiccating species, (C. Tyler-Smith, Ed.). PLOS Biol. 16: e2004830. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.2004830

Vakhrusheva O. A., E. A. Mnatsakanova, Y. R. Galimov, T. V. Neretina, E. S. Gerasimov, S. A. Naumenko, S. G. Ozerova, A. O. Zalevsky, I. A. Yushenova, F. Rodriguez, I. R. Arkhipova, A. A. Penin, M. D. Logacheva, G. A. Bazykin, and A. S. Kondrashov, 2020 Genomic signatures of recombination in a natural population of the bdelloid rotifer Adineta vaga. Nat. Commun. 11: 6421. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-020-19614-y

Weismann A., 1887 On the signification of the polar globules. Nature. 36:607–609. https://doi.org/10.1038/036607a0

About the author:

Charles H. Langley is Distinguished Professor of Genetics at the University of California, Davis.

, , ,

Guest posts are contributed by members of our community. The views expressed in guest posts are those of the author(s) and are not necessarily endorsed by the Genetics Society of America. If you'd like to write a guest post, e-mail communications@genetics-gsa.org.

View all posts by Guest Author »

Read more in

  • Thank you, GSA community!

    Thank you for being a member of the Genetics Society of America! As GSA’s current president, I am writing to tell you about Society projects and initiatives that we hope you will find useful in advancing your science and your career. Scientific research is a collaborative and exciting endeavor. Scientific societies like GSA exist to…

  • Collage of 2021 Rosalind Franklin Award recipients

    Where are they now? Rosalind Franklin Young Investigator Award recipients share updates on their research

    Rosalind Franklin Young Investigator Award applications are open–make sure you submit your application or nomination of a colleague by September 30, 2024.

  • University of Minnesota researchers map genome of the last living wild horse species

    The study, published in G3: Genes|Genomes|Genetics, is part of larger conservation efforts to save Przewalski’s horse.

  • Congratulations to the Spring 2024 DeLill Nasser Awardees!

    GSA is pleased to announce the recipients of the DeLill Nasser Award for Professional Development in Genetics for Spring 2024! Given twice a year to graduate students and postdoctoral researchers, DeLill Nasser Awards support attendance at meetings and laboratory courses. The award is named in honor of DeLill Nasser, a long-time GSA supporter and National Science Foundation…

  • Carolyn Damilola headshot

    Carolyn Damilola: an NFS Rising Scientist on a lifelong quest to learn more

    Carolyn Damilola is an NFS Rising Scientist from Nigeria doing respiratory system research and paving the way for scientists from underrepresented communities through mentorship.

  • Text over a blue background image: Apply for up to $2,000 for your project from the Starter Culture Microgrant Program.

    What does a good microgrant proposal look like?

    Members of the Microgrant Review Committee share their tips for a successful proposal.

  • A blurred image of a human face is shown against a dark background.

    The first piece of the facial recognition puzzle

    New research in GENETICS gives a first peek at the molecular pathway involved in recognizing faces.

  • New Senior Editor Amy MacQueen joins GENETICS

    A new senior editor is joining GENETICS in the Genome Integrity and Transmission section. We’re excited to welcome Amy MacQueen to the editorial team.

  • Close up of an adult zebrafish with blue and white stripes in an aquarium with red lighting.

    Block party on the zebrafish sex chromosome

    Research in G3 identifies a gene regulatory block of the zebrafish genome responsible for overseeing the maternal-to-zygotic-transition.

  • Lemna Minor, the common duckweed

    Unraveling the mysteries of duckweed: epigenetic insights from Spirodela polyrhiza

    Research published in G3 offers insight into the impact of DNA methylation on clonal propagation in asexually reproducing plants.

  • Luciano Marraffini headshot

    A microbiologist’s quest to understand CRISPR in bacterial self-defense

    2024 Genetics Society of America Medal recipient Luciano Marraffini determined how CRISPR-Cas systems destroy genetic targets with precision, paving the way for gene editing technology development.

  • Elaine Ostrander headshot

    Unlocking mysteries of trait and disease heritability in dogs

    2024 Edward Novitski Prize recipient Elaine Ostrander, a pioneer of the domestic dog model, discovered numerous genes affecting dog size, morphology, behavior, and disease susceptibility—many of which have relevance in humans.

  • NSF-funded BIO-LEAPS Grant to Support Culture Change in Genetics

    GSA and collaborators Personal Genetics Education & Dialogue and Reclaiming STEM Institute launch NSF-funded BIO-LEAPS project to support culture change in genetics 

    We are thrilled to announce that the Genetics Society of America (GSA) is collaborating with the Personal Genetics Education & Dialogue (PGED) based in the Department of Genetics at Harvard Medical School, and the Reclaiming STEM Institute (RSI) on a Leading Culture Change Through Professional Societies of Biology (BIO-LEAPS) grant from the U.S. National Science…

  • Daman Saluja: Navigating Science and Policy in India

    In the Paths to Science Policy series, we talk to individuals who have a passion for science policy and are active in advocacy through their various roles and careers. The series aims to inform and guide early career scientists interested in science policy. This series is brought to you by the GSA Early Care­er Scientist…

  • Deborah Andrew headshot

    A fly geneticist’s journey into discovering rules of organ development

    2024 George W. Beadle Award recipient Deborah Andrew discovered new genes and pathways in Drosophila salivary gland organogenesis. Now, her work can help optimize cell secretion in therapeutic applications and fight malaria.

  • Małgorzata Gazda's headshot

    Małgorzata Gazda: How receiving the DeLill Nasser Award helped her land her dream job

    Have you ever experienced an event that changes the course of your life, or in this case, your career? Małgorzata (Gosia) Gazda is Assistant Professor at the University of Montreal and in 2022, she received the DeLill Nasser Award for Professional Development in Genetics, which she used to attend and present at the 2022 Population,…

  • Hongyu Zhao joins GENETICS as new Senior Editor

    A new senior editor is joining GENETICS in the Statistical Genetics and Genomics section. We’re excited to welcome Hongyu Zhao to the editorial team.

  • Julio Molina Pineda at TAGC 2024

    GSA Member Julio Molina Pineda Receives DeLill Nasser Award, Shines at TAGC 2024 

    “At any career stage, the GSA membership is an amazing investment for any genetics professional!” Julio Molina Pineda is a PhD Candidate in Cell and Molecular Biology and a Research Assistant at the University of Arkansas, and a Doctoral Academy Fellow at the Lewis Lab. In 2023, Julio was awarded the DeLill Nasser Award for…

  • Ed Grell at his dissecting microscope using ether to anesthetize his flies.

    In Memoriam: Ellsworth Herman Grell (1932–2023), a pioneer of Drosophila genome engineering and annotation

    Ellsworth (Ed) Grell blessed the Drosophila community through three enduring legacies: as a pioneer of chromosome mechanics, as a primary organizer and synthesizer of genetic knowledge in Drosophila, and as a graceful mentor to those fortunate to have known him personally. Ed grew up in rural Nebraska, completed his undergraduate studies at Iowa State, and…

  • Congratulations to the #Fungal24 Poster Award winners!

    We are pleased to announce the recipients of the GSA Poster Awards for posters presented at the 32nd Fungal Genetics Conference! Undergraduate and graduate student members of GSA were eligible for the awards, and a hard-working team of judges made the determinations. Congratulations to all! Felicia Ebot Ojong, The University of Georgia My research is focused…

  • Poster presentation tips for TAGC 2024

    You’ve been selected to present a poster at The Allied Genetics Conference 2024 in March—you’ve celebrated, made plans to attend, now what? This is an exciting opportunity to showcase your research and engage with fellow members of the genetics community, so you want to make sure you’re prepared. We wanted to offer you some tips…

  • Maximize your TAGC 2024 experience 

    A guide to all that National Harbor & DC have to offer Are you joining us for The Allied Genetics Conference 2024 in March? Make the most of your #TAGC24 experience in National Harbor! We know the science will keep you busy, but you deserve to unwind and have some fun, so we’ve curated a…

  • Early Career Leadership Spotlight: Sarah Petrosky

    We’re taking time to get to know the members of the GSA’s Early Career Scientist Committees. Join us to learn more about our early career scientist advocates. Sarah PetroskyMultimedia SubcommitteeUniversity of Pittsburgh Research Interest I am interested in understanding adaptation that has been happening recently in populations by dissecting the ways that genes underlying an adaptation…

  • TAGC 2024 Early Career Award Winners

    GSA is pleased to announce the winners of the early career awards presented at The Allied Genetics Conference 2024. These awards are specific to particular TAGC communities and recognize early career scientists’ outstanding work on their respective research organisms. The awardees will present their talks in keynote sessions at TAGC 2024.  Don’t miss the opportunity…

  • Preeminent geneticists recognized with revamped GSA Awards

    In 2022, GSA’s Board of Directors launched an audit to review the five major awards conferred by the Society. Today, we are thrilled to announce the recipients of the reimagined GSA Awards, including the new Genetics Society of America Early Career Medal. The scientists honored this year are recognized by their peers for their outstanding…

  • Fly Board funds outreach programs to spread the word about Drosophila research

    In 2020, the Fly Board voted to use part of its reserve fund to support efforts to increase trainee participation as well as equity and diversity in the Drosophila community. An awards committee decides how the money will be spent each year, and from 2020–2022, the committee posted a very broad call for applications from…

  • New members of the GSA Board of Directors: 2024–2026

    We are pleased to announce the election of four new leaders to the GSA Board of Directors: 2024 Vice President/2025 President Brenda Andrews Professor, University of Toronto It’s an honor to continue my association with the Society by serving as Vice President of the Board of Directors. I have broad knowledge of the ongoing activities…

  • New members of the GSA Board of Directors: 2025–2027

    We are pleased to announce the election of six new leaders to the GSA Board of Directors: 2025 Vice President/2026 President Cassandra Extavour Timken Professor of Organismic & Evolutionary Biology and of Molecular & Cellular Biology, Harvard University, and Howard Hughes Medical Institute Investigator “Read this,” he said, “it will change your life.” My undergraduate…

  • Congratulations, Spring 2025 Victoria Finnerty Travel Award recipients!

    The Victoria Finnerty Undergraduate Travel Award supports conference-attendance costs for undergraduate GSA members who are presenting research at the Annual Drosophila Research Conference. #Dros25 will be held in San Diego, CA from March 19–23, 2025. Victoria Finnerty, who died in February 2011, was a long-time member of the Genetics Society of America and served the Drosophila community and the genetics community at large in…

  • Meet embGAN, a revolution for cell lineage studies

    New research in GENETICS reports an automated pipeline for cell lineage tracing that massively reduces manual analysis time.