The vibrant passion-vine butterfly species Heliconius erato doesn’t taste as good as it looks. The flesh of this South and Central American species accumulates toxic compounds to discourage would-be predators, who quickly learn to associate the butterflies’ unpleasant taste with their bold red warning colors and patterns.
But H. erato isn’t the only species that wears this particular danger sign. Another foul-tasting relative, H. melpomene, has evolved an almost identical set of markings. In fact, even though the wing patterns of H. erato vary across its geographic range — from red-banded to red-rayed to so-called “postman” marks — this variation is mirrored nearly everywhere by matching patterns of H. melpomene. In other words, each species looks different in different places, but wherever their ranges overlap, the two species mimic one another.
For more than a century, biologists have used Heliconius as a model of mimicry, an adaptation that has been observed in not only insects, but also fish, reptiles, amphibians, and perhaps birds. Across the Heliconius genus, mimicry is remarkably prevalent, including large coalitions of Heliconius species that live alongside assorted unrelated butterflies and day-flying moths that have all converged on a single warning pattern.
In the June issue of GENETICS, Kronforst and Papa review the genetics of wing patterning in Heliconius, charting how rapidly-expanding genomic knowledge of the system promises to provide insights into some of the oldest questions about adaptive processes.
Approximate distributions of the three major phenotypes and locations of many subspecies of co-mimics H. erato and H. melpomene. Matching wing-color-pattern variation and subspecies names are shown below the maps. At each location (numbered) the local sub-species of H. erato and H. melpomene show similar wing color patterns. Common themes among these patterns allow them to be grouped into three general categories: red-banded (1-8), rayed (9-16), and “postman” (17-21). (Two incipient species that are part of the H. erato radiation, H. himera and H. erato chestertoni, are also indicated).
The first biologist to explain how mimicry might evolve was explorer-naturalist Henry Walter Bates. Inspired by data collected on an epic expedition to the Amazon with his friend Alfred Russel Wallace, Bates’ 1862 proposal was one of the first applications of the radical new theory developed by Wallace and Charles Darwin — evolution by natural selection. In his butterfly surveys, Bates noticed that palatable and unpalatable species sometimes shared nearly identical warning patterns. He reasoned that the more delicious varieties gained a selective advantage by mimicking the patterns used by the unpleasant tasting species. This type of mimicry is now known as Batesian.
But what about when both species are unpalatable, like H. erato and H. melpomene? Why should either species bother to mimic another bad-tasting bug when it has its own chemical defenses?
The explanation was provided in 1878 by Fritz Müller, another Amazon butterfly-catcher inspired by the ideas of Darwin and Wallace. He argued it came down to the cost of training the predators to recognize which wing patterns were off the menu. When näive birds try to eat a unappetizing butterfly, they will steer clear of similar looking bugs in the future — but the encounter may well be fatal for the taste-tested butterfly. By sharing the same warning pattern, the two Heliconius species speed the process of predator learning, and divide the risk of being eaten. It’s a case of strength in numbers that increases each individual’s chance of survival.
Fritz Müller was a German naturalist who lived for 45 years in Brazil. Inspired by his observations of Brazillian butteflies, he was the first to explain how an unpalatable species might gain an advantage from mimicking another unpalatable species. His argument was also one of the first examples of using mathematical arguments to support an evolutionary explanation.
Because this type of mimicry—known as Müllerian— is so widespread in Heliconius, the group has become the primary model for understanding the phenomenon. The power of this model has rapidly expanded in recent years, thanks to a co-ordinated international effort to understand the genetics of its wing patterning.
These efforts have identified a number of mimicry loci that control similar aspects of wing patterns in different species. For example, across all Heliconius species the optix gene is critical for specifying red coloration, while WntA specifies black patterning.
Along with the assembly of the H. melpomene genome, these molecular details are giving rise to a number of evolutionary insights. For example, it has become clear that mimicry in Heliconius evolves by several mechanisms. In some cases, similar wing patterns independently evolve in co-mimicking species through different mutations in the same genes. In other cases, the two species directly exchanged adaptive variants via interbreeding.
Kronforst and Papa illustrate a number of other ways that genetic discoveries are helping reveal the mechanisms of mimicry and shedding light on more general questions in evolutionary biology. In the age of genomics, we can now trace the molecular details of evolutionary processes that Müller and other pioneers could only infer from the pretty colors traced on butterfly wings.
CITATION:
Kronforst, M. R., & Papa, R. (2015).
The Functional Basis of Wing Patterning in Heliconius Butterflies: The Molecules Behind Mimicry.
Genetics, 200(1), 1-19. doi:10.1534/genetics.114.172387
http://www.genetics.org/content/200/1/1
Cristy Gelling is a science writer, lapsed yeast geneticist, and former Communications Director at the GSA.
View all posts by Cristy Gelling »Read more in
-
Hongyu Zhao joins GENETICS as new Senior Editor
A new senior editor is joining GENETICS in the Statistical Genetics and Genomics section. We’re excited to welcome Hongyu Zhao to the editorial team. Hongyu ZhaoSenior Editor Hongyu Zhao is the Ira V. Hiscock Professor of Biostatistics, Professor of Genetics, and Professor of Statistics and Data Science at Yale University. He received his BS in…
-
GSA Member Julio Molina Pineda Receives DeLill Nasser Award, Shines at TAGC 2024
“At any career stage, the GSA membership is an amazing investment for any genetics professional!” Julio Molina Pineda is a PhD Candidate in Cell and Molecular Biology and a Research Assistant at the University of Arkansas, and a Doctoral Academy Fellow at the Lewis Lab. In 2023, Julio was awarded the DeLill Nasser Award for…
-
In Memoriam: Ellsworth Herman Grell (1932–2023), a pioneer of Drosophila genome engineering and annotation
Ellsworth (Ed) Grell blessed the Drosophila community through three enduring legacies: as a pioneer of chromosome mechanics, as a primary organizer and synthesizer of genetic knowledge in Drosophila, and as a graceful mentor to those fortunate to have known him personally. Ed grew up in rural Nebraska, completed his undergraduate studies at Iowa State, and…
-
Congratulations to the #Fungal24 Poster Award winners!
We are pleased to announce the recipients of the GSA Poster Awards for posters presented at the 32nd Fungal Genetics Conference! Undergraduate and graduate student members of GSA were eligible for the awards, and a hard-working team of judges made the determinations. Congratulations to all! Felicia Ebot Ojong, The University of Georgia My research is focused…
-
Poster presentation tips for TAGC 2024
You’ve been selected to present a poster at The Allied Genetics Conference 2024 in March—you’ve celebrated, made plans to attend, now what? This is an exciting opportunity to showcase your research and engage with fellow members of the genetics community, so you want to make sure you’re prepared. We wanted to offer you some tips…
-
Maximize your TAGC 2024 experience
A guide to all that National Harbor & DC have to offer Are you joining us for The Allied Genetics Conference 2024 in March? Make the most of your #TAGC24 experience in National Harbor! We know the science will keep you busy, but you deserve to unwind and have some fun, so we’ve curated a…
-
Early Career Leadership Spotlight: Sarah Petrosky
We’re taking time to get to know the members of the GSA’s Early Career Scientist Committees. Join us to learn more about our early career scientist advocates. Sarah PetroskyMultimedia SubcommitteeUniversity of Pittsburgh Research Interest I am interested in understanding adaptation that has been happening recently in populations by dissecting the ways that genes underlying an adaptation…
-
TAGC 2024 Early Career Award Winners
GSA is pleased to announce the winners of the early career awards presented at The Allied Genetics Conference 2024. These awards are specific to particular TAGC communities and recognize early career scientists’ outstanding work on their respective research organisms. The awardees will present their talks in keynote sessions at TAGC 2024. Don’t miss the opportunity…
-
Preeminent geneticists recognized with revamped GSA Awards
In 2022, GSA’s Board of Directors launched an audit to review the five major awards conferred by the Society. Today, we are thrilled to announce the recipients of the reimagined GSA Awards, including the new Genetics Society of America Early Career Medal. The scientists honored this year are recognized by their peers for their outstanding…
-
Fly Board funds outreach programs to spread the word about Drosophila research
In 2020, the Fly Board voted to use part of its reserve fund to support efforts to increase trainee participation as well as equity and diversity in the Drosophila community. An awards committee decides how the money will be spent each year, and from 2020–2022, the committee posted a very broad call for applications from…
-
New members of the GSA Board of Directors: 2024–2026
We are pleased to announce the election of four new leaders to the GSA Board of Directors: 2024 Vice President/2025 President Brenda Andrews Professor, University of Toronto It’s an honor to continue my association with the Society by serving as Vice President of the Board of Directors. I have broad knowledge of the ongoing activities…